home > paid book/ebook

A Trial by Jury

Customer Reviews:

A Jury of One

By Amy Sterling Casil - August 25, 2002

I found this book in the library and at the time, had no knowledge of its publisher's heavy push, its substantial hardcover printing, or the author's 10-city book tour as mentioned in the PW and other reviews. It seemed interesting, and the jacket blurbs referring to "Twelve Angry Men" were appealing. Other reviewers have stated simply the differences between what the book jacket promises, and what's in the book. Literature, especially this type, responds to the world; it does not direct it. I've heard dozens of people complain about jury duty, and dozens more say that it's pointless. Despite Professor Burnett's statements to the contrary (after these pages of complete self-obsession and disrespect for his fellow jurors, and every living being in the courtroom with the possible exception of the sommnolent history-loving bailiff) - his "affirmations" that the jury system still works, although men like his fellow juror Felipe should not be allowed to sit - this book tells... read more

Why Academics Make Lousy Jurors

By steve davis - December 14, 2002

I've been a trial lawyer for more than 30 years. I've tried both civil and criminal cases. Currently I am a prosecutor. So I was interested in Burnett's book because it promised to give me a glimpse of how a jury conducts itself in deliberations. If the jury Burnett served on in Manhattan is any indication, it's like the saying that it's better not to see how sausage is made.
I don't fault all the members of this jury... A more alert prosecutor would have struck him at the outset when he observed him segregating himself from the rest of the jury panel, nibbling his fruits and nuts and reading his newspaper in the corner.
It is not the verdict the jury ultimately reached that is offensive. If the jury wanted to entertain a reasonable doubt whether or not the defendant acted in self defense, that was its prerogative. But to sit around and debate justice vs. the law for four days was simply a jury out of control, led by an academic who apparently operates on such a... read more

The idea is great; the author, case and jury are less so

By P. Meltzer - November 8, 2001

The idea for this book was certainly a good one. Given how the whole jury system plays such a central role in our judicial system, it is rather surprising that there is so little material on what actually goes in inside the jury room. As Burnett rightly points out, it is a "largely inaccessible space in our society." Thus the book is certainly a step towards filling that void. That said, I found it somewhat unsatisfying for several reasons, some of them within the author's control and some of them not. In various other reviews here, the author has been described variously as "pretentious" (on several occasions), "pompous", "snobbish", "holier-than thou", "smug", and "self-congratulatory". Anyone see a theme here? I don't really disagree with any of these and I would add pedantic, condescending and superior. It really comes through on almost every page. And yet, I have to say that with the possible... read more

Use coupon below to get discount at eCampus.com!

SHADES
$3 off textbook orders over $75

SUNBLOCK
$4 off textbook orders over $90

SUNSHINE
$5 off textbook orders over $100

Copy the coupon code before clicking the button!

AVAILABILITY
MerchantFormatPrice
Amazon USPaperback$0.01 - $14.00
BookBytePaperback$9.75
eCampusPaperback$1.50 discount!
PREVIEW
Related Documents
An Essay on the Trial by Jury

An Essay on the Trial by Jury

$20.47

An Essay on the Trial by Jury

Is Trial by Jury Worth Keeping?

Is Trial by Jury Worth Keeping?

$11.90

Is Trial by Jury Worth Keeping?

An Essay on the Trial By Jury

An Essay on the Trial By Jury

$26.08

An Essay on the Trial By Jury

The Institution of Trial by Jury in India

The Institution of Trial by Jury in India

$14.78

The Institution of Trial by Jury in India

Vocal Score of the Sorcerer and Trial by Jury

Vocal Score of the Sorcerer and Trial by Jury

$11.40

Vocal Score of the Sorcerer and Trial by Jury

Treatise on Trial by Jury: Including Question of Law and Fact With an Introductory Chapter on the Origin and History of Jury Trial

Treatise on Trial by Jury: Including Question of Law and Fact With an Introductory Chapter on the Origin…

$52.65

Treatise on Trial by Jury: Including Question of Law and Fact With an Introductory Chapter on the Origin and History of Jury Trial

An Essay on the Defense of Prisoners by Counsel: With Suggestions for an Improvement in That Part of the Trial by Jury

An Essay on the Defense of Prisoners by Counsel: With Suggestions for an Improvement in That Part of…

$12.44

An Essay on the Defense of Prisoners by Counsel: With Suggestions for an Improvement in That Part of the Trial by Jury

Imagining the Anglo-Saxon Past: The Search for Anglo-Saxon Paganism and Anglo-Saxon Trial by Jury

Imagining the Anglo-Saxon Past: The Search for Anglo-Saxon Paganism and Anglo-Saxon Trial by Jury

$90.00 - $92.63

Imagining the Anglo-Saxon Past: The Search for Anglo-Saxon Paganism and Anglo-Saxon Trial by Jury

Law & Order: Trial by Jury Characters

Law & Order: Trial by Jury Characters

$8.10

Law & Order: Trial by Jury Characters

loading