home > paid book/ebook

A Source Book in Chinese Philosophy

Customer Reviews:

A few reservations.....

By Gary Arbuckle (garbuckl@direct.ca) - June 1, 1998

I use this book in teaching, and am very grateful for it. However, there are a few "gotchas" that the reader/student should be aware of.First, it's old. It was done in 1963 and won't be revised, since the author is dead. It thus has a very "traditionalistic" selection of texts, with philosophy more narrowly defined than I feel comfortable with. And of course, it doesn't include any of the textual discoveries since 1963, or any of the groundbreaking textual work, such as Graham's on the Chuang-tzu. There are major authenticity problems with some of the selections from the Kung-sun Lung-tzu and Tung Chung-shu as well.Second, even for its time, it's conservative. The author was, to put it kindly, credulous about some early datings. The discussion of the Lao-tzu is particularly problematic. There is also an overly dismissive attitude towards the thought of some periods, such as the Han.Third, it's somewhat biased, though in a very traditional way. The... read more

Source Book in Chinese Philosophy

By Marilyn H. Dorato - April 23, 2000

Dr. Chan was my college Asian philosophy professor so I used the book under special circumstances. As I recall, it was to be a beginning for those interested in the subject and was not intended to satisfy those further along in their studies. He was always receptive to differing views, and I think, would have been pleased to argue his points. He might be called conservative, but it was not easy for intellectuals still stuck in Mao's China as he was as a young man. He told us of having to read in the toilet so no one would know. The book is very simply written, easy for a novice to grasp and structured in such a way as to encourage discussion about the various philosophers. I recommend it for those with a budding interest in the subject. It gives a good overview and would encourage most readers to go on. No book should be read without the possibility of questioning what it contains just as no teacher should ever be regarded as the ultimate authority.

A useful, but often problematic, anthology.

By bryan12603 - November 15, 2000

We owe a great debt to the late Professor Chan for having translated this anthology of selections from over 2,500 years of Chinese philosophy. To my knowledge, this is the only anthology that gives so many selections from so many different periods in Chinese history. Perhaps there never will be a book like this again, at least by one scholar, because I doubt anyone else is competent to translate so many texts from so many different periods.That being said, this book also has serious limitations. Arbuckle's review (which is nearby) expertly identifies many of them. Here are some more. Chan's English is much better than my modern Chinese, but he still sometimes lapses into incoherence. With a few exceptions, his comments on the translations are both confusing and confused. Chan likes to use Western philosophical terminology, but he is not in command of it. It is neither accurate nor helpful to describe the Ch'eng-Chu wing of Neo-Confucianism as "rationalistic," and... read more

Use coupon below to get discount at eCampus.com!

SHADES
$3 off textbook orders over $75

SUNBLOCK
$4 off textbook orders over $90

SUNSHINE
$5 off textbook orders over $100

Copy the coupon code before clicking the button!

AVAILABILITY
MerchantFormatPrice
Amazon USPaperback$0.99 - $49.95
eBooks.comDigital (PDF)$49.95
BookBytePaperback$59.16
eCampusPaperback$46.31 discount!
PREVIEW
Related Documents
Ngugi Wa Thiong'O: The Making of a Rebel : A Source Book in Kenyan Literature and Resistance (Documentary Research in African Written Literature 1)

Ngugi Wa Thiong'O: The Making of a Rebel : A Source Book in Kenyan Literature and Resistance (Documentary…

$90.00 - $99.95

Ngugi Wa Thiong'O: The Making of a Rebel : A Source Book in Kenyan Literature and Resistance (Documentary Research in African Written Literature 1)

A Source Book in Mathematics, 1200-1800

A Source Book in Mathematics, 1200-1800

$103.35

A Source Book in Mathematics, 1200-1800

A Source Book in Chemistry, 1400-1900

A Source Book in Chemistry, 1400-1900

$115.54 - $128.50

A Source Book in Chemistry, 1400-1900

The Way of Water and Sprouts of Virtue (Suny Series in Chinese Philosophy and Culture)

The Way of Water and Sprouts of Virtue (Suny Series in Chinese Philosophy and Culture)

$2.00 - $19.95

This book maintains that early Chinese philosophers, whatever their philosophical school, assumed common principles informed the natural and human worlds and that one could understand the nature of ...

Zaha Hadid: BMW Central Building Source Book in Architecture 7 (Source Books in Architecture)

Zaha Hadid: BMW Central Building Source Book in Architecture 7 (Source Books in Architecture)

$15.73 - $29.95

Zaha Hadid's highly inventive and seemingly unbuildable designs have defied conventional ideas of architectural space and construction. The BMW Central Building in Leipzig, Germany, is no exception. ...

Theories of Modern Art: A Source Book by Artists and Critics (California Studies in the History of Art)

Theories of Modern Art: A Source Book by Artists and Critics (California Studies in the History of Art)…

$0.31 - $32.95

Gathers interviews, articles, letters, and manifestos dealing with Postimpressionism, symbolism, fauvism, Expressionism, and cubism.

Human Dimension and Interior Space: A Source Book of Design Reference Standards

Human Dimension and Interior Space: A Source Book of Design Reference Standards

$4.86 - $39.95

The study of human body measurements on a comparative basis is known as anthropometrics. Its applicability to the design process is seen in the physical fit, or interface, between the human body and ...

The birth primer: A source book of traditional and alternative methods in labor and delivery

The birth primer: A source book of traditional and alternative methods in labor and delivery

$6.74

The birth primer: A source book of traditional and alternative methods in labor and delivery

Jew in the American World: A Source Book, by Marcus

Jew in the American World: A Source Book, by Marcus

$20.20

Jew in the American World: A Source Book, by Marcus

Jew in the Medieval World: A Source Book, 315-1791, by Marcus

Jew in the Medieval World: A Source Book, 315-1791, by Marcus

$2.00 - $24.95

An updated reprint of a sourcebook for the study of medieval Jewry.

loading