home > paid book/ebook

Out of Our Heads: Why You Are Not Your Brain, and Other Lessons from the Biology of Consciousness

Customer Reviews:

An accessible and compelling exploration of the extended mind

By Todd I. Stark "Cellular Wetware plus Books" - March 30, 2009

The mind is more than what the brain is doing. The idea isn't new, but it often gets too little respect. Perhaps because people think it implies something supernatural, or perhaps because it just seems weird, but it is a very respectable argument and in Alva Noe's hands, a powerful one.

We often take for granted in brain science that the mind is implemented by things happening inside the skull. That goes against the growing findings that perception is an active process of exploration that depends on our contact with the real world and the skills we possess for navigating its structure. This book takes on the significant challenge of bringing that difficult idea accessibly and non-technically into the popular mind and I think he does an excellent job.

Although Noe doesn't talk about it specifically, Ruth Millikan makes a good related argument that substance categories are really skills. We know substances by our skills for finding and identifying them over... read more

"You are not your brain."

By Found Highways - March 8, 2009

Or, to use another of philosopher Alva No?'s metaphors, "consciousness is more like dancing than it is digestion." Consciousness is something we do, not something we have. Our awareness of ourselves isn't inside our brains, but in the interaction of our brains with the world around us.

One of the ideas that No? insists on is that our "theory of mind" (the awareness that other people, like us, are conscious) is practical, not theoretical.

No? says, "I cannot both trust and love you and also wonder whether, in fact, you are alive in thought and feeling." To put it another way, No? quotes Louis Armstrong on how to define jazz: "If you gotta ask, you ain't never gonna know."

To see something's mind, "we need to turn our attention to the way brain, body, and world together maintain living consciousness."

Using language as an indicator of consciousness, No? may just be reaching for effect when he says that "talking is more like barking than it is... read more

Intriguing But Flawed

By Robert W. Sawyer "Roberto W" - August 17, 2009

I appreciate Noe's expansive view of the conditions of human experience, and his battle against simplistic reductionism. Materialist-minded neuroscientists, like many specialists, overstate the significance of their own research, and in a psychiatric context can do more harm than good.

But Noe's single-minded focus on the role of active engagement in everyday-life phenomenology leads him to overstate his own case.

It isn't clear, for example, why an organism's active engagement with its environment, a precondition for normal perception, should count toward a definitive account of "consciousness", while model-building neural activity in the brain shouldn't, unless you're simply assuming about consciousness what you wish to prove, i.e., that it isn't in any way its neurological correlates.

Noe also goes too far in his insistence on environmental engagement as a necessary precondition for consciousness. One of his own examples - patients with locked-in... read more

Use coupon below to get discount at eCampus.com!

SHADES
$3 off textbook orders over $75

SUNBLOCK
$4 off textbook orders over $90

SUNSHINE
$5 off textbook orders over $100

Copy the coupon code before clicking the button!

AVAILABILITY
MerchantFormatPrice
Amazon USPaperback$4.22 - $15.00
eBooks.comDigital (PDF)$9.99
eCampusPaperback$2.71 discount!
PREVIEW
Related Documents
Autopsy of an Engine: and Other Stories from the Cadillac Plant

Autopsy of an Engine: and Other Stories from the Cadillac Plant

$0.01 - $14.00

“Autopsy of an Engine is the most surprising love story I’ve read all year. The workers in the Cadillac factory who populate this book may not be related, but in the hands of ...

Why I Am Not A Christian And Other Essays On Religion And Related Subjects

Why I Am Not A Christian And Other Essays On Religion And Related Subjects

$6.98 - $36.98

Originally published in 1927, this early work of philosophy is both expensive and hard to find in its first edition. It contains Russell’s logical argument as to why the Christian religion is ...

Sports Illustrated: Hate Mail from Cheerleaders and Other Adventures from the Life of Rick Reilly

Sports Illustrated: Hate Mail from Cheerleaders and Other Adventures from the Life of Rick Reilly

$0.01 - $16.95

Soon after best-selling author Rick Reilly started writing a weekly back-page column for Sports Illustrated, he tackled the subject of cheerleading. Reilly wrote: "I don't hate cheerleading just ...

Fraud Casebook: Lessons from the Bad Side of Business

Fraud Casebook: Lessons from the Bad Side of Business

$29.98 - $73.95

Praise for Fraud Casebook Lessons from the Bad Side of Business"I have known Mr. Wells for over twenty years. In my opinion, no one in the world knows more about fraud than he does."

ALOS* and other tales from the private psychiatric hospital.: *average length of stay

ALOS* and other tales from the private psychiatric hospital.: *average length of stay

$10.96 - $11.95

A.L.O.S. is a collection of true tales from the private psychiatric hospital as told by former therapist and psychiatric program director, Dan Shattuck, M.Ed. The work is rich with sadness ...

Mousepads, Shoe Leather, and Hope: Lessons from the Howard Dean Campaign for the Future of Internet Politics (Media & Power) (Media and Power)

Mousepads, Shoe Leather, and Hope: Lessons from the Howard Dean Campaign for the Future of Internet…

$2.16 - $24.95

Howard Dean's campaign for president changed the way in which campaigns are run today. With an unlikely collection of highly talented and motivated staffers drawn from a variety of backgrounds, the ...

Text Me If You're Breathing: Observations, Frustrations and Life Lessons From a Low-Tech Dad

Text Me If You're Breathing: Observations, Frustrations and Life Lessons From a Low-Tech Dad

$3.79 - $14.95

What does a Dad do when his eight year old asks Santa for a Wii Fit and a 4G iPhone? The answer is simple: laugh! In Text Me If You're Breathing, stand-up comedian and technically challenged dad Greg ...

Not Bloody Likely -- and other Quotations -- from Bernard Shaw

Not Bloody Likely -- and other Quotations -- from Bernard Shaw

$3.94 - $39.00

This is a collection of the best of the playwright's witticisms and other turns-of-phrase, in which Shaw often unmasks the truth with humor and style. Dukore's introduction surveys Shaw's passion for ...

You Are Not Alone: Erik And Christine

You Are Not Alone: Erik And Christine

$21.40

You Are Not Alone: Erik And Christine

You Are Not Your Diagnosis

You Are Not Your Diagnosis

$16.14

You Are Not Your Diagnosis

loading