ACrimeWorseThanLorenaBobbitt:HowaCostaMesaWomanCommitted
theUltimateActofMaritalRevenge
Crimestoriesrarelymakethenationalnews,butinthefewcasestheydoitisbecausetheyinvolveaterrorenoughto
strikefearintotheheartofthegeneralpublic. ItcouldbeacaselikeScot PetersonorTedBundy,playingoffthefear
thataseeminglynormal,charmingmanmightbecapableofmurder,orthatamotherlikeSusanSmithorCasey
Anthonymightactual ywanttomurderthechildrenshebroughtintotheworld.
Crimestoriesplayintopeople'smostprimalfears,whichiswhywithinhours,thearrestofCatherineKieuBecker
becamenationalnews.Spousalabusecasesarerarelynoteworthy,butinthiscaseBeckerdidsomethingdramatic
enoughtojustifybothanentirecourseworthofFreudianstudiesandamonologueoflatenightjokes:shecutoffher
husband'spenis.
Mencanresteasythatthisissuchanuncommonoccurrencethatwhenitdoeshappen,itusual ybecomesnational
news.Themostprominentexampleofthisisthe1993caseofJohnandLorenaBobbit ,inwhichLorena,aftera
historyofmaritalabuse,decidedinadrunkenragetocutoffherhusband'spenisandthrowouttheseveredmember.
Lorenawasjudgednotguiltyduetotemporaryinsanity,John'speniswasreat achedandhestarredinseveraladult
films,andBobbit becameahouseholdnamesincetheincident.
TheBobbit story mayhavebeenonMrs.Becker'smindwhenshecommit edhercrime. Aftercut ingoffher
husband'spenis,sheensuredthatitcouldnotbereat achedbyplacingitinthegarbagedisposal.Infact,herentire
crimewasfarbet erconceivedthanMrs.Bobbit 's.Shedruggedherhusbandandtiedhimupbeforecut ingoffher
penis,unlikeMrs.Bobbit ,whodidsowhileherhusbandwassleepingandinadrunkenrage.
YetwhileCatherineKieuBeckerundoubtedlyhadthemoreaccomplishedplancomparedtoLorenaBobbit ,there's
lit lechancethatshewil faceajurywil ingtoacquitlikeMrs.Bobbit .Asofyettherearenoaccusationsofspousal
abuse between theBeckers as inthe Bobbit case; Mrs. Beckerwasreportedly motivatedbya dispute over
houseguestswithherhusband,andthetwowereplanningdivorce.Furthermore,Mrs.Becker'splanningofthecrime
suggestspremeditation,whilethecircumstancesofLorenaBobbit 'scrimeweremoreimpulsive;shedrunkenlypicked
uptheknifeanddecidedtotakeherrevenge,whereaseverythingaboutMrs.Becker'scrimeseemscareful yplanned
(druggingherhusbandandtyinghimupbeforecut ingoffthepenis).
CatherineKieuBeckerwaschargedwithseveralcrimesuponherarrest.Theseincludefelonytorture,aggravated
mayhemwithenhancementsforgreatbodilyinjuryandpersonaluseofaknife.Thechargeoftortureisrelativelyself
evident,butforalaypersonthechargeofaggravatedmayhemseemsodd.Mayheminthevernacularhasabroad
definition,general ydescribinganysituationinwhichthereiswidespreadpanicorterror,butitactual yhasaspecific
commonlawdefinitionadoptedbythestateofCalifornia.
Thetermmayhemactual yreferstodismemberment,cut ingoffapartofanotherperson'sbody. UnderCalifornialaw,
onecanbeconvictedofmayhemthroughthemalicioususeofforcetodisableordismemberapartofanother
person'sbody,whetherslicingof anarm,gougingoutaneyeorevenslit ingthenose,earsorthroatofaperson.
Aggravatedmayhem,thecrimeforwhichMrs.Beckerwascharged,involvesanextremeorrecklessdisregardforthe
physicalorpsychologicalwel beingofthevictim.Onesuspectsthateventhemostincompetentprosecutorcould
provethatcut ingoffaman'spenisandthenthrowingitinthegarbagedisposaldisplaysanextremedisregardforher
husband'sphysicalwel being,letalonehispsychologicalwel being.
ThecaseofCatherineKieuBeckerwil thereforeunlikelyendpoorlyforbothherandherhusband. Ifonecansaythat
acaseofpeniledismembermenthadahappyending,thatiswhathappenedwiththeBobbit s:Johnrecoveredfrom
hisinjuryandparlayeditintoashortlivedfame,andLorenawasacquit ed,livedasurprisinglynormallife,andlater
foundedanorganizationfordomesticabusevictims.Mr.Beckerwil inal likelihoodnotbereunitedwithhismissing
bodypart,andMrs.Beckerfaceslifeinprisonforwhatappearstobeapremeditatedcrime. Inthiscase,thereareno
winners,exceptperhapsJayLenoandSigmundFreud.
TheauthorbringsthecaseofCatherineKieuBecker'smaritalrevengewhichhasturnedintoanationalnews.Also
comparinghercasewiththatoftheBobbit s,makingDomesticViolenceAttorneyvigilantofsuchharshcrimes.
By:JeremyRossat DomesticViolenceLawyer
Add New Comment