Personal Exposure Assessment to Air Toxics in BRTs: Metrobus Insurgentes, Mexico City
0.00 (0 votes)
Document Description
Personal exposure assessment to air toxics in BRTs: Metrobus Insurgentes, Mexico City Seventh Annual Transforming Transportation Washington, D.C. January 13 th, 2010 Beatriz Cárdenas González Instituto Nacional de Ecología Outline…
Trust n Deal Realty Offering Ready to Move Flats in Greater Noida. Supertech Czar Suites are ready to move flats in Greater Noida. Czar Suites comprises of Studio, 2, 3 and 4 Bedrooms apartments, ...
In this article, our main focus is how to solve limits in calculus? But, before we
move to this question, let's have a look on Limits.
Limits, are used to find the value of any given function f(x) at ...
In this article, our main focus is how to solve limits in calculus? But, before we
move to this question, let's have a look on Limits.
Limits, are used to find the value of any given function f(x) at ...
http://www.vietnamtravels.com/ Vietnamtravels.com offers full travel services: visa to Vietnam, Tour in Vietnam, Cruises Halong, Cruises Mekong, Sapa trekking and overland adventure in Vietnam. Get ...
DODAggregator software, a hosted daily deal aggregate platform. The software, which will be launched
from DODAggregator, is a daily deal aggregate platform designed to let individuals create their ...
DODAggregator software, a hosted daily deal aggregate platform. The software, which will be launched from DODAggregator, is a daily deal aggregate platform designed to let individuals create their ...
Content Preview
Personal exposure assessment to air toxics in BRTs: Metrobus Insurgentes, Mexico City Seventh Annual Transforming Transportation Washington, D.C. January 13 th, 2010 Beatriz Cárdenas González Instituto Nacional de Ecología
Outline
INE: air pollution, transportation, GHG
The impact of a Bus Rapit Transit System on Commuter‘s exposure to air pollutants in Mexico City: Metrobus Insurgentes 2004-2005
Current projects:
Zero Emisions Corridor, Mexico City 2008
Ruiz Cortines Corridor, Monterrey 2009
Lessons learned and Next steps
Credits -
INE
Adrian Fernández, President
Leonora Rojas and Victor Gutiérrez Avedoy
Project participants
Henry Wöhrnschimmel, Beatriz Cárdenas, Miriam Zuk *
Gerardo Martínez**, Julia Cerón
Salvador Blanco, Arturo Campos, Jepthé Cruz, Teresa Ortuño
CTS
Adriana Lobo, Hilda Martínez
Nuevo León State Goverment
Idolina de la Cerda, Juan Marin, Jaime Garza
Hewlett Fundation
Embarq
INE Climate Change Program Ecosystems conservation Chemicals, Urban and Regional pollution National Center for Environmental Research and Training Environmental Policy and Economy Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment National Institute of Ecology (technical and scientific branch)
Trends of Air quality in Mexico City Metropolitan Area: Ozone and CO Source: http://www.sma.df.gob.mx/simat2/ Ozone Carbon monoxide (CO)
Trends of PM in Mexico City Metropolitan Area Source: Retama, 2009. http://www.sma.df.gob.mx/simat2/
Trends of the different PM fractions in MCMA Source: Retama, 2009. http://www.sma.df.gob.mx/simat2/
Trends of PM2.5 in Mexico City Metropolitan Area Source: Retama, 2009. http://www.sma.df.gob.mx/simat2/
Carbon monoxide trends in Mexico city: in public transportation (personal exposure) and ambient air Personal exposure concentration Ambient concentration Introduction of Catalytic converter Mexico City air monitoring network
Inventario Nacional de Emisiones de Gases de Efecto Invernadero 2006 . Contribución por sector (INE, 2009) 711 million of tons CO 2 eq./year Sources: INEGEI 2006. Instituto Nacional de Ecología 2009 Fixed and area sources Transportation waste Change of soil use and agriculture Industrial processes Fugitive emissions Energy Power plants 20.7% Construction and manufacturing 7.9% Other sectors (residential included) 4.4%
Shiohara, N., Fernández-Bremauntz, A., Blanco-Jiménez, S. and Yanagisawa, Y., 2005. The commuters’ exposure to volatile chemicals and carcinogenic risk in Mexico City . Atmospheric Environment 39, 3481–3489. Volatile organic compounds in public transportation in Mexico City
Marr, L. C., Grogan, L. A., Wöhrnschimmel, H., Molina, L. T., Molina, J. M., Smith, T. J., Garshick, E. (2004) Vehicle traffic as a source of particulate polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon exposure in the Mexico City Metropolitan Area . Environmental Science and Technology (38) pp. 2584-2592 PAHs in public transportation
Assessment of commuter´s personal exposure to air pollutants Metrobús Insurgentes, Mexico City (2004-2005) Zero Emissions Corridor Eje Central México City (2008-baseline) in progress BRT Ruiz Cortinez Corridor Monterrey, Nuevo León (2009-baseline) in progress
CO, PM 2.5 , PM 10 and benzene (before and after Metrobus 2004 2005 Metrobus Insurgentes
Detroit: Batterman et al., 2002 Sidney: Duffy and Nelson, 1997 Taichung: Kuo et al., 2000 Taipei: Chan et al., 1994 Boston: Chan et al., 1992 Raleigh: Chan, 1991 London: Bevan, 1991 Mexico: Shiohara et al., 2005 Gómez-Perales et al., 2004 INE/UAMI/GDF-SMA 2009 Tula: INE/UAMI 2008 Salamanca: INE/IEG/UAMI 2007 Monterrey: INE/CTS/APMARN/CETYV 2009 Benzene indoor levels reported in different cities PM2.5 personal Exposure reported in the world
Helsinki: Scotto di Marco et al., 2005 Hong Kong: Chan, 1999 Paris: Dor et al., 1995 Amsterdam: Van Wijnen et al., 1995 Athens: Vellopoulou et al., 1998 Duci et al., 2003 Guangzhou: Chan et al., 2002 Mexico: Gómez-Perales et al., 2002 London: Kaur et al., 2005 CO personal Exposure reported in the world
Detroit: Batterman et al., 2002 Sidney: Duffy and Nelson, 1997 Taichung: Kuo et al., 2000 Taipei: Chan et al., 1994 Boston: Chan et al., 1992 Raleigh: Chan, 1991 London: Bevan, 1991 Mexico: Shiohara et al., 2005 Gómez-Perales et al., 2002 Benzene personal Exposure reported in the world
Studies on personal Exposure reported inMexico Año Ruta Modo Referencia 1991 Indios Verdes – San Ángel ; Tacuba – Pantitlán, Pino Suarez – Xochimilco; La Villa – Auditorio; Marina Nacional – Pantitlán Auto particular, combi, microbús, autobús , metro, trolé, tren ligero Fernández-Bremauntz & Ashmore, 1995 2002 Indios Verdes – San Ángel ; Tacuba – Pantitlán, La Villa – Auditorio; Microbús, autobús , metro Gómez et al., 2004 2003 Indios Verdes – San Ángel ; La Villa – Auditorio; Microbús, autobús Gómez et al., 2007 2004 Indios Verdes – San Ángel Auto particular, Microbús, autobús Wöhrnschimmel et al., 2008
Study objective
determine reduction in commuters’ exposure to air pollutants that may result from a change from a conventional bus transport system to a BRT system.
Insurgentes
Methods
Measurements of PM 10 , PM 2.5 , benzene and carbon monoxide invehicle concentrations in conventional public transport and modern vehicles of a BRT system .
Number of measurements 2004 Minibus 2004 Bus 2005 Metrobus PM 10 35 34 55 PM 2.5 33 35 51 Benzene 29 29 53 CO 35 34 51
Results
Significant reductions in personal exposures inside vehicles of the BRT system between
32% and 59% were found for air pollutants associated with vehicular emissions.
Commuting times dropped by about 20%
Cobenefits Metrobus Insurgentes
Emissions reductions tons/per year
144 HCT
690 NO X
2.8 PM
1.3 SO 2
Health impacts avoided
6,100 lost days
600 days of restringed activities
12 new cases of acute broquitis
3 premature deaths
Economic benefits (yearly)
3 millions USD in health cost
1.3 m trip time
12.3 m net benefit
280,000 tons of CO 2 eq reductions Source:INE
Before
Only “trolebus”
Confined line
Reduccion in traveling time and emissions
Reduction in personal exposure to air pollutants
Improvement of urban
Zero emissions Eje Central
Different routes and different vehicles for public transportation (trolebus, bus, minibus)
Confined line and use of different lines
Longer time
Zero Emissions Corridor Eje Central in Mexico City
Field measurements in June-July 2008 Field campaing for personal exposure assessment in Eje central
Team 1.- Trolebús
team 2.- mix route
Team 3.- rotatino mix and trolebus
team 4.- bus stop
Field campaing for personal exposure assessment in Eje central
Bus stop Sampler at 1 m height (to simulate breathing zone) Field campaing for personal exposure assessment in Eje central
Carbon monoxide Eje Central Base line for Zero emissions corridor Autobús (1991): 38 ppm Microbús (1991): 55 ppm Microbus (2004) bus (2004) Metrobús (2005)
PM2.5 Eje Central Base line for Zero emissions corridor Micro-, Autobús (2004) Metrobús (2005)
PM composition*: elemental carbon vs. Organic carbon Eje Central Base line for Zero emissions corridor * Subsample
BTX Eje Central Base line for Zero emissions corridor
BTX Eje Central Base line for Zero emissions corridor Microbús (2004) Autobús (2004) Metrobús (2005)
Travel time Resultados – línea base Eje Central Base line for Zero emissions corridor
Summary
Trasnportation (public and prive) is an micro-environment with hihg exposure to air pollutants
Differences in air pollutant concentrations and time being exposed to them result in different communter`s exposure
Demonstrated reductions in communter`s exposore to air pollutants with Metrobus Insurgente
Potential to use this data and transform into indicators
Personal exposure assessment studies could be used to support the implemntation of BRTs but ...
questions should be asked
Critical mass and analytical infraestructure need to be expanded
Communicate what is already available
Potential to share experiences and learn from mistakes
Assertive communication
Conclusions
BRT systems have the potential to reduce in-vehicle concentrations of air pollutants in comparison to conventional transport modes.
The additional reduction of commuting times further decreases total exposure and thus the health impact of commuting .
BRT systems contribute to increased quality of life of public transport users.
Next steps
Field campaign at the Zero Emissions corridor
Field campaign at the Monterrey Corridor
Identify needs of information
Other cities
Other partners
Gracias [email_address] www.ine.gob.mx
Share Personal Exposure Assessment to Air Toxics in BRTs: Metrobus Insurgentes, Mexico City to:
Download Personal Exposure Assessment to Air Toxics in BRTs: Metrobus Insurgentes, Mexico City
Add New Comment